
On November 17, 1998, lawyers for the ice cream company Ben and Jerry’s argued before the National Labor Relations Board against the efforts of their employees to form a union. This minor but pretty disgusting episode in late twentieth century labor history demonstrated how the so-called socially conscious capitalism that came out of the counterculture was just as anti-worker as JP Morgan or Henry Clay Frick or Jack Welch could imagine.
Back in the 60s and 70s, there was a vision, at least among “mainstream” culture, that hippies were lazy and didn’t work. But that wasn’t true, or at least not always. In fact, the counterculture had all sorts of ideas about work. Some of them were on communes, an issue I’ve explored before in this series. Others made products that seemed alternative at the time but in fact could easily enter mainstream markets. Since many in the counterculture came from pretty well-off backgrounds and had at least started in college before turning on and dropping out or whatnot, they had skills and resources they could later use to start their own businesses. These businesses could easily portray themselves as a different kind of capitalism.
Ben & Jerry’s is a great example. Founded in 1978, it not only brought great domestically made ice cream onto the American market (I’ve always wished for more fruit or nut oriented flavors, but I’m not questioning the quality), but they could say that they weren’t just about making profit, but giving back and creating socially useful products. And whatever you want to say about ice cream, it wasn’t napalm or plastics. Jerry Greenfield and Ben Cohen might appear at anti-nuke rallies or rallies to reduce the defense budget. They gave to charities. They supported environmental causes. But what about their own workers?
Ben & Jerry’s might not have been the worst employer in the world, but their workers had every right to a union. In 1998, their maintenance workers at the St. Albans, Vermont facility decided to unionize. They went to the International Brotherhood of Electrical Workers for help. IBEW was happy to provide representation. The workers had reasonable demands. See, the company demanded long hours and demanded flexibility on how those hours were divided. It would not provide the federally required time-and-a-half pay until workers reached 40 hours a week. But it often required long hard 10 hour days. The workers wanted overtime to be granted after eight hours in any given day. This was especially common on holiday weeks. See, sure the company would give these workers Labor Day or Memorial Day off. But they demanded 40 hours a week nonetheless, so the rest of the week was tremendously hard and when you are doing the kind of work that happens in a food facility, the danger levels rise rapidly when you get tired. They took their demands to management before approaching IBEW. After all, these socially conscious hippies should understand these things, right? Wrong. Management totally blew the workers off.
The workers wanted to join the union. But of course that required an election. Ben & Jerry’s hired anti-union lawyers. They made a classic argument–these dissatisfied workers shouldn’t be allowed to form a union. Rather, if there was going to be one, then all the workers should get to join it. Isn’t that democracy? But of course a lot of the other workers weren’t working in such conditions and they didn’t necessarily want a union. The NLRB rejected Ben & Jerry’s argument here. The workers had an election and they won that election.
But Ben & Jerry’s being anti-union was all too typical of an entire generation of supposedly lefty business people and much of the lefty general public too who were a lot more comfortable with capital than they were unions. Individualistic freedom was the order of the day–let your freak flag fly–and no one was going to tell them what to do, not Lyndon Johnson, not Richard Nixon, not George Meany. People might form communal groups and do work within them, but everything was entirely voluntarily. Making money could be fun and so let’s do that too and in this individualistic ethos, how dare the workers come in and tell me what to do?
This was hardly the only company in the late 90s and early 00s who promoted their ideas of socially responsible capitalism that failed on the shoals of giving their own workers rights. Powell’s Books in Portland is another example. Its workers are well-known today for having a union, but management fought it hard at the time and still often seeks to undermine that union to the present. When Powell’s unionized in 1999, its founder Michael Powell said that unions destroy freedom of speech.
Starbucks tried to claim some socially responsible capitalism but Howard Schultz was about to play the Pinkerton himself when Starbucks workers sought to unionize nearly a decade ago now; none have a contract to the present. Whole Foods is notoriously anti-union, with its founder John Mackey comparing unions to herpes.
Borders was another great example–founded by hippies in the early 70s, it became the second largest bookseller in the world by the late 90s. It provided same-sex partner healthcare benefits long before this was required by law (although you had to pay into it and it was really expensive and they didn’t pay employees enough to make this realistic for almost anyone). But when its workers tried to unionize, it raised holy hell to stop them.
In short, the 60s hippies had almost zero class analysis and that has continued to the present as this group ages into its Trumpist era. Although Ben & Jerry’s, after selling out to Unilever, has tried to retake control of its politics and supports a lot of good causes, the cause of worker rights is one place where socially conscious capitalists almost always fall short.
It’s real simple–if you claim to be a liberal, just recognize the union. That’s all you have to do. Say OK and open bargaining. Don’t fight it. I was once a member of Theda Skocpol’s Scholars Strategy Network. When her workers wanted a union, this noted liberal refused to recognize it and forced an election, which the workers won. So I left it and told her in an email why. I was like, why can’t you just recognize the union? But they never do. Put up or shut up supposed liberals. If you don’t support the unionization of your own workplace, you aren’t a liberal. You’re just another capitalist.
In 2024, the Ben & Jerry’s workers at the Waterbury, Vermont plant joined United Food & Commercial Workers Local 371. Unilever, smarter than Ben or Jerry themselves, just agreed to neutrality and did exactly what you should do as employer–card check. You get a majority of workers to sign up, you have your union.
I borrowed from Liza Featherstone’s “‘It’s Business, Man!’ Unions and ‘Socially Responsible’ Corporations,” originally published in Dissent in 1999, but since republished in Nelson Lichtenstein and Samir Sonti, Labor’s Partisans: Essential Writings on the Union Movement from the 1950s to Today.
This is the 620th post in this series. Previous posts are archived here.
The post This Day in Labor History: November 17, 1998 appeared first on Lawyers, Guns & Money.
A fully playable web-slinging Spider-Man looks out over <em>Arkham Knight</em>'s Gotham City, thanks to AI coding tools.
Credit: