17740 stories
·
175 followers

How 4Patriots and My Patriot Supply Cashed In on Prepping for the Apocalypse | WIRED

2 Shares
How two big names in mainstream disaster preparedness helped sell Americans on fear, anxiety, and a new generator.
4Patriots chief engineer Tyler Stapleton demonstrates a 4Patriots Patriot Pure Personal Water Filter Straw by drinking out of a toilet on September 10, 2025, in Lindon, Utah.Photograph: SINNA NASSERI

When it comes to prepping, look to the Mormons. It’s right there, in the official name of the religion: To be a “Latter-day Saint”' is explicitly to believe in, and prepare for, the end times. This is why, on a calm morning last September, I arrive just outside Salt Lake City in a place called American Fork and knock on the door of Tyler Stapleton, the chief product engineer for off-grid power products at 4Patriots, one of the biggest companies pushing preparedness into the mainstream. Church members play outsize roles in this multibillion-dollar industry—a global concern where politics and technology collide, with sales fueled by social media and conspiracy theories, in addition to the undeniable rise in world chaos.

Stapleton is a bit sheepish but very nice, a nerdy mechanical engineer with degrees from Brigham Young University who lives with his wife and three young children. Inside their tidy home is a big clock, a bright kitchen, and the Book of Mormon on the shelf. After exchanging pleasantries, Stapleton begins showing off new products and prototypes, including a sleek “James Bond-like” solar generator that packs up like a briefcase. All the while, he sticks to the company line, telling me that the typical owner of a 4Patriots power product is not some zealot in camouflage preparing to live in a bunker “for days on end” but rather a family man seeking “energy independence” for the occasional moments when the grid goes down. It’s a well-placed piece of rhetoric, though the line loses some of its luster an hour later, when Tyler lets slip that his childhood home nearby does, indeed, feature a modest bunker, then reluctantly agrees to take us to it.

4Patriots’s Tyler Stapleton in his father’s cellar in Lindon, Utah.

Photograph: SINNA NASSERI

Stapleton emerges from from the cellar—technically different from a bunker, although serving largely the same purpose of safety.

Photograph: SINNA NASSERI

Today, the US government advises every citizen to build a disaster kit and concoct plans for an array of cataclysms. According to a 2023 survey from the Federal Emergency Management Agency, 51 percent of Americans are in some way “prepared for a disaster.” This helps explain why the prepping industry’s market cap is forecast to be nearly $300 billion by the end of the decade. Two of the firms competing for market share have nearly identical names and offer the same basic slate of products: power generators, dehydrated food, and water filtration. There’s Stapleton’s employer, 4Patriots, and its rival, My Patriot Supply. While exact revenue figures are difficult to pin down, officials at My Patriot Supply tell me that, before the pandemic, they rented part of a 45,000-square-foot space; today, the company built and fully utilizes a 428,000-square-foot warehouse not far from Stapleton’s home.

These two firms are aggressively jockeying to be the industry’s true patriot prepping company, with one official from My Patriot Supply claiming that 4Patriots is their “archnemesis.” My Patriot Supply is particularly bellicose, deeming the other company and its competitors “fake patriots”in a video. Meanwhile, both firms have notched their share of consumer complaints with government and business watchdogs over the years. 4Patriots customers have alleged that the company produces faulty water filters, defective generators, and dubious food. One person said their order was rife with roaches, while another claimed the company's Aztec Chili with Mango made them “can’t leave the bathroom sick” for a week. (According to the Better Business Bureau website, someone associated with 4Patriots replied to this alleged complaint a day later, adding, "I'm so sorry that you had many issues after consuming the survival food kits.”) In 2016, the company voluntarily recalled a couple thousand generators due to an unforeseen fire hazard, and consumer complaints allege their generators continue to suffer from potentially dangerous electrical defects. (After putting 4Patriots’ 1,800-watt solar generator through lab testing, Consumer Reports rated it 46 out of 100.) Certainly, recalls and bad reviews are part and parcel of many businesses today, though an explicit part of the pitch from 4Patriots and its competitors is the rock-hard reliability of their goods when disaster strikes.

In a comment to WIRED, a 4Patriots official said the company shipped over 5 million products to consumers over the past three years and that it places “product quality and customer safety above all else.” He declined to detail the company’s return or refund rates, asserting that to equate those numbers with “product failure or customer dissatisfaction would be inaccurate.”

Stapleton, for his part, is bullish about the current generation of 4Patriots’ generators. We end his house tour in the kitchen, where he volunteers to demonstrate the company’s AlphaCase suitcase-sized generator, a product that is “powerful enough,” he says, to run his refrigerator. As he shimmies it out from a kitchen wall, Stapleton talks excitedly about the incredible advances in battery technology pioneered in recent years by firms like Tesla. “It’s competitive, and that’s a good thing,” Stapleton says. “There’s a lot of people pushing the envelope on what’s possible. And so we are working hard to stay ahead of that.”

As the climactic moment arrives, Stapleton unplugs his fridge and hooks it up to the 4Patriots power pack. It buzzes quietly for a few seconds, then emits a beeping sound. At this point, a message shoots up on the screen. “That’s just the overload message,” Stapleton awkwardly explains, adding that “this guy”—meaning his generator, which he had just said would run a refrigerator and which the website claims, too—is “a little bit small for powering fridges.”

The garden at Stapleton’s father’s home.

Photograph: SINNA NASSERI

When, in the mid-1800s, the Mormons first fled west to the Utah Territory, they viewed prepping as a means of survival and autonomy from government persecution. They subsequently formed an off-grid society, with the church operating its own bank, printing its own currency, and directing a militia. In an October 1980 speech before thousands in Salt Lake City, church leader Ezra Taft Benson articulated a far more practical ethic of preparedness. A well-studied farmer, Benson spearheaded the reintroduction of missionary work in Europe following World War II. In his speech, Benson recalled the “terrible physical and social side effects of hunger” he witnessed in the wake of the war, his voice breaking with emotion. “Too often,” he said, “we bask in our comfortable complacency and rationalize that the ravages of war, economic disaster, famine, and earthquake cannot happen here.”

Mormons, of course, were not the only group of Americans to worry about the future; Boy Scouts who hope to become Eagles have long needed to earn an Emergency Preparedness Merit Badge. In their 2024 book, Be Prepared: Doomsday Prepping in the United States, Robert E. Kirsch and Emily Ray trace how American prepping has long been wed to consumerism through its alluring pitch to “purchase your way to safety.” Today, America’s roulette wheel of routine calamity includes extreme heat, power grid overload, crop failure, water contamination, climate-change-induced natural disasters, climate-change-induced disease, government shutdowns, political corruption, troops in the streets, fervent militia activity, mass shootings—and, new for 2026, regime change in Latin America. It also seems that every few years an asteroid just barely misses Earth.

Final Famine, a book by Teddy Daniels stocked at the My Patriot Supply warehouse in Salt Lake City.

Photograph: SINNA NASSERI

Founded in 2008, 4Patriots initially focused on food, appealing to people who started stocking emergency rations after the election of Barack Obama. Its unlikely founder is Allen Baler, who has an English degree from Obama’s law school alma mater, Harvard, and a corporate marketing background, traits that My Patriot Supply has spoofed in YouTube content showing a Baler-esque figure in a Harvard half-zip who resorts to “scarcity” tactics and other cynical sales tricks.

The face of the firm back then was Frank Bates, a slick pitchman and Vietnam veteran living near Nashville, Tennessee, who wrote about how Obama's policies had hurt his family, his business, and America. He alleged various government plots, including one that the FEMA was hoarding food because “it knows that if you control the food supply, then you control the people.” When the company’s emergency offerings expanded into power supplies, 4Patriots teased the “dirty little secret that President Obama and the big energy monopolies have been trying to bury.”

4Patriots once described its core customer base as “55+ year-old conservatives in ‘red’ states with a strong sense of self-reliance.” Baler first tapped into this constituency in 2011, with an ad buy at a then-fledgling conservative news outlet called Newsmax, a hub, in his words, of “affluent, conservative men who surprisingly like to buy a lot of stuff online.” He subsequently expanded his messaging to The National Review, Glenn Beck’s conservative news network, The Blaze, and then Fox News, which has repeatedly plugged 4Patriots products on air.

In 2014, ThinkProgress alleged that Bates wasn’t real. They could find no one in Nashville with his name and background. Then the site discovered his likeness on a stock image site, captioned “friendly man with arms crossed.” 4Patriots denied any deception and, to this day, occasionally features materials signed by the mysterious Mr. Bates. (On its FAQ page, 4Patriots assures longtime customers that Bates is, indeed, real but that he uses a pen name “to protect his privacy.”) In general, 4Patriots has toned things down, presumably to reach other constituencies, like crunchy off-gridders, tailgaters, campers, and people living in hurricane zones or tornado alley. Still, according to Stapleton, the firm’s customer base continues to include “a lot of conservative individuals.”

Stapleton in his garage in American Fork, Utah, near Salt Lake City.

Photograph: SINNA NASSERI

Both of the patriotic prepping companies promote their products through traditional TV ads and active YouTube channels. My Patriot Supply also produces podcast-style content about the various dangers that necessitate a prepping mindset, while its competitor has launched 4Patriots University, a set of preparedness master classes taught weekly by Seth Weller, a wiry former Boy Scout (and scoutmaster), who has been working in preparedness for a quarter-century. Weller insists that his curriculum focuses strictly on developing contingencies and building community support networks, not pushing product. He argues that too many Americans use prepping as a form of “retail therapy,” buying products “to remove that fear” without building the requisite expertise to actually use them.

Weller’s long career on the front lines of American prepping has made him a canny diagnostician of the emotional currents fueling the phenomenon. In his estimation, many of his clients have experienced some sort of profound loss, whether it’s heartache, the death of a loved one, or a storm. “It’s not necessarily some major catastrophic event, but it’s something that changed their lives,” he tells me. “And in that process, they realized that this happened because, well, they had a dependency. And then they turn around, like, ‘I don’t ever want to feel that again.’ So, they realize they have to gain some control. They’ve got to gain independence.”

When I ask Weller what thrust him into this world, he points not to an earthquake or a flood but to the painful and unexpected loss of his luxury port-a-potty and shower trailer business. He seems genuinely driven to help people secure calm from their anxieties, arguing that it’s interpersonal prepping networks and skills that can best meet this challenge, not simply gear from prepping companies, which, Weller candidly admits, doesn’t always work.

Unprompted, Weller invokes a hypothetically wonky generator, bought “under the guise” that it can power a critical household appliance, only for the lights to go out and the consumer to realize that the product “doesn’t work.” Obviously unaware of my prior experience in Stapleton’s kitchen, Weller claims that 4Patriots has risen above this shoddy consumerism. “It’s not just about selling products for us,” he assures me. “It’s about truly helping them out.”

Fire starter sold by My Patriot Supply at the company’s warehouse in Salt Lake City.

Photograph: SINNA NASSERI

One of Weller’s longtime protégés is Gary Eiler, an Air Force veteran who, in the fall of 2018, was caught in the vortex of Hurricane Michael. At the time, Eiler owned an 800-unit climate-controlled storage facility in Panama City, Florida, called HBO Storage. (It stood for Home, Business, Office.) While Michael was initially predicted to make landfall in Louisiana, it hooked north at the last minute, rapidly intensified to a Category 5, and barreled directly toward Panama City where Eiler was standing watch. As winds topped out at 160 miles per hour, the storm stripped the roof off Eiler’s business like a sardine can. Then the walls started collapsing. Eiler found cover under a bolted-down service counter, where he huddled for more than six hours. “It was very emotionally trying,” he confesses.

As the wind settled, Eiler became fixated on a question Weller had posed in a class he taught prior to his 4Patriots employment: “How long do you have in an emergency before societal breakdown ensues?” Eiler says Panama City turned to bedlam in about 20 minutes after the wind died down. Hordes of citizens began looting the stores around him, including a Goodyear auto shop, an off-brand rent-a-center, and a grocery store called Food City. Eiler went to sleep that night in the collapsed ruins of his business, the sounds of screams and gunfire punctuating the air. (News reports show that the storm indeed inflicted massive infrastructure damage and took the lives of 19 people. There were also sustained reports of armed looters, but also waves of fear that crashed across communities, leading one Florida state cop to shoot and kill a civilian who allegedly tried to steal a law enforcement vehicle.)

Eiler spent two months stationed at his destroyed store, overseeing his customers’ belongings with a stern face and a Taurus pistol. In the first two weeks, he collected and filtered water off the section of the roof that was still intact and prepared freeze-dried food, remembering Weller’s specific instructions to cook it in such a way as to avoid constipation, which, Eiler remarks, “you don’t want to deal with in an environment like the one I was in.” Indeed, he was then defecating in a bucket. Eventually his brother was able to breach the city in an RV filled with food, clothes, more weapons, and other survival gear supplied by Weller and friends. “It was a war zone,” Eiler concludes. “I’ve only been to Panama City two other times since the storm because of the anxiety it brings me. And that’s because my sister lives here.”

Prepared dishes from 4Patriots survival food kit.

Photograph: SINNA NASSERI

Another of Weller’s star students at 4Patriots University is Bill Knapp, whose worries, unlike Eiler’s, were crystalized by an event that never happened. In 1998, Knapp was at Deloitte, where he helped the firm prepare for Y2K, work that first exposed him to the grid’s fragility. Ahead of New Year’s Eve, Knapp stocked up on water and food and bought a generator. Nothing happened, though during one summer shortly after, he says, a hurricane came through his community on Long Island and knocked out power for 10 days.

Knapp connected with 4Patriots three and a half years ago when, during a routine Google search for a cell phone charger, he found the company’s solar-powered block. Knapp today estimates that he has spent roughly $60,000 on prepping, much of it to support the construction of an off-the-grid tiny house, but also more than $7,000 alone in 4Patriots gear. He grouses that people “accuse you of hoarding, but I'm not hoarding. I’m investing.”

Along the way, Knapp brought his new wife, Pat, into the fold. One of his first gifts to her when they were dating included a 4Patriots emergency kit for her car trunk, replete with thermal blankets and food should any chaos arise on I-95. When the two tied the knot last summer, they gifted some of their guests 4Patriots’ small device chargers. The couple has since converted the front lawn of their Maryland home to a flower garden, to support pollination, and grow food out back that doesn’t touch pesticides. After they discovered that their city water supply had allegedly been polluted with forever chemicals by the company that produces Gore-Tex fabric, they bought a new water filtration system.

Despite all this, Pat seems slightly more tentative of prepping than her husband. More specifically, she doesn’t love the constant vigilance that prepping culture can require. “Because of 4Patriots, whenever we go anywhere, we’re assessing,” she tells me, articulating the newfound hyperalertness that has suffused her life. “If it was not for 4Patriots, I would not be thinking this way. What are we taking? Are we going to a crowd? Are we staying away from a crowd? It’s dangerous to be out on the road, it really is. But we try to enjoy our lives. We try to balance—and we talk about this—how to balance out our negative vibes.”

Pat expresses especially acute concern about the have and have-not dynamics that pervade any major disaster. “I’m not so sure I’m gonna be strong enough to turn somebody away if they need food.” She continues: “I’ve just started learning how to shoot. And I’m thinking, am I gonna be able to pull a gun out and shoot somebody because they’re trying to … ”

“Steal from us,” Bill finishes.

“ … steal from us,” Pat echoes. “Or hurt Bill. These are the types of things we discuss in the chat rooms.”

The threat of atomic annihilation was the catalyzing fear of the boomer prepper, while many younger ones point to 9/11. Other major events in modern prepping lore include Hurricane Katrina, the Ebola outbreak, and then, in quick succession, the 2020 Covid pandemic, the 2021 Texas power grid outage, and Russia’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine. Sources from both Patriot companies told me that presidential elections also routinely goose sales. One explained that after Donald Trump was reelected in 2024, “we knew that sales were going to plummet, and they did.” He later muses, “I’m genuinely confused why the Left doesn’t start getting prepared.”

When I entered Stapleton’s home on the morning of September 10, all was normal. Thirty minutes later, though, news broke that right-wing activist Charlie Kirk had been gunned down at Utah Valley University, just nine miles south of American Fork. By the time I descended into the Stapleton family’s subterranean bunker, Kirk’s killer was still on the loose.

A few hours later, in front of the hospital where Kirk’s body was being held, I witnessed a vigil of grieving Americans. One was Kelsie Gruenewald, a member of the Latter-day Saints wearing a red, white, and blue T-shirt and holding an American flag. As it turns out, she owns various shelf-stable food products from 4Patriots. In a later interview, Gruenewald tells me that her prepping instincts have hardened in response to various forces, including the day of March 18, 2020, when a 5.7 magnitude earthquake shook Salt Lake City just as Covid-19 was shutting the entire country down. She was again shocked when her abundantly safe, generally moderate home state was struck by political violence. “Evil,” she said, “can creep up anywhere.”

Stapleton eats a pasta dish from the company’s survival food kit.

Photograph: SINNA NASSERI

4Patriots meals shown in Stapleton’s father’s cellar.

Photograph: SINNA NASSERI

Once Stapleton has awkwardly tested the generator, he calls over to the 4Patriots warehouse for a delivery of food and water supplies. While waiting, I get lunch nearby at the One Man Band Diner. The man running the register is pale and fixated on the television. His daughter was at Kirk’s speech, though by the time of my arrival, she has thankfully been accounted for. I eat next to a deeply tanned carpenter. He tells me he’s had plenty of clients ask him to build a bunker but that, generally, it’s more trouble than it’s worth. “It’s a secretive thing, but you still have to get it permitted,” he explains with a shrug.

The bunker has become the most conspicuous symbol of tinfoil prepping, a mindset nurtured by cynical prepping figures like Chris Turpin, the CEO of the Be Prepared Expo, located in Farmington, Utah. He told one reporter a couple years back that “preparedness helps you from eating your neighbor.” One lapsed Mormon working at a Utah prepping company, who requested anonymity to speak candidly about the industry, is conflicted over how his firm, and others, capitalize on fear. He says that some people “catch an extreme streak” and “go real wild with it,” then mentions a friend whose house not only holds a massive stockpile of food but is also outfitted with trap doors “filled with ammo and guns and precious metals.”

After lunch, it’s time to cook up and photograph some food back at Stapleton’s childhood home. It features the staples of Mormon self-reliance: a lush garden, apple trees, chickens, and a basement and bunker stocked with enough food to, in my layman’s estimation, last a lifetime. Stapleton is 4Patriots’ power guy, but still, he gamely navigates the stove while earnestly plugging the product. “Were talking actual recipes, meals,” he explains cheerfully, not simply “mashed potatoes and beans.”

When our recipe for chocolate pudding demands dairy, we dip into the bunker for dehydrated milk. There, amid 10-foot shelves of beans, corn, pineapple, and other essentials, I spot a 32-gallon can of chocolate milk powder called Morning Moo. I comment incredulously about the incalculable volume of pure happiness that powder must produce. “You never know, man,” Stapleton responds with a cheeky smile. The pudding is serviceable, but the macaroni and cheese is a bit chalky. The pasta is hard, though it’s quite possible we didn’t boil it long enough.

Jake Seawolf (left) and Gideon Kai, influencers and photographers for My Patriot Supply, eat the company’s survival food.

Photograph: SINNA NASSERI

The next day, two Latter-day Saints in the employ of My Patriot Supply take me on a tour of their warehouse. Both have blond hair and goatees. The two strenuously emphasize the quality and value of their products over certain unnamed competitors. “A lot of companies will say ‘Look how many servings, look at the weight,’ but they don’t tell you how many calories,” Jared Arvidson, the company’s sales director, explains. “We build pretty much all of our kits 2,000 calories and up. Because you want to be able to live on the food, not just survive.” (4Patriots later tells me it includes caloric information on its food products and also that it harbors no ill will toward its major competitor. My Patriot Supply, for its part, didn’t respond to emailed questions or requests for comment, sent after the tour.)

As we walk the echoey warehouse, Seth McCausland, SVP of manufacturing and operations, also points to the durability, reseal-ability, and UV protective properties of the company’s food pouches, which, he notes, “could be buried under rubble at some point, or they could go through extreme heat or get buried in water from flooding.”

I am offered a sample of one of their higher-quality food products: a Tuscan sun-dried tomato and sausage pasta. It’s delicious. This, I’m told, is thanks to My Patriot Supply’s in-house food scientist, who they say previously helped invent Subway’s famous raspberry cheesecake cookies. He now formulates nutritionally effective end-of-world meals, in part by boosting them with a proprietary vitamin and mineral blend.

The warehouse floor at the My Patriot Supply warehouse in Salt Lake City.

Photograph: SINNA NASSERI

The staff at My Patriot Supply contend that they avoid fearmongering, a point the company emphasizes in a YouTube video showing the Baler stand-in cowering on the ground while warning about murder hornets. Near the end of the tour, however, I see, amid stacks of inventory, a series of books by a doomsaying prepper named Teddy Daniels. His titles include Devil’s Dollar: How to Survive the Final War on Christians and Final Famine: How to Keep Your Family Fat and Happy While the World Starves. Arvidson quickly clarifies that the firm no longer sells these products—and indeed they’re not for sale online—then shuffles us off to another section. Later, though, I find social media content from the company verging on conspiratorial, including a chart it shared on X depicting all the Chinese-owned farmland next to military bases. In later research, I also found a clip of Glenn Beck plugging the firm’s heirloom seed packets.

Sales director Jared Arvidson at the My Patriot Supply warehouse.

Photograph: SINNA NASSERI

A calendar at the My Patriot Supply warehouse.

Photograph: SINNA NASSERI

In 2022, the two companies leveled dozens of claims and counterclaims against each other before the National Advertising Division, an independent non-profit with links to the Better Business Bureau, regarding everything from the integrity of their online reviews to the quality of their products. In the end, the division dinged both companies on similar fronts, recommending, for instance, that 4Patriots avoid conveying to consumers that its survival food kits “provide consumers with the abundance of food depicted in the advertising for the full claimed duration,” while urging My Patriot Supply to stop indicating that its food kits included fresh fruit. Both companies were also criticized for how they sought to juice the review landscape, either by withholding negative feedback, in the case of My Patriot Supply, or, for 4Patriots, through failing to properly disclose its financial endorsements of certain product review videos.

Like siblings born in too-quick succession, My Patriot Supply and 4Patriots seem to be squabbling over their similarities as much as their differences. They both exist to sell a sense of security in a rapidly destabilizing world. The threats are certainly real, even if the exact solution—a new generator, a shelf stable meal—might not always be so satisfying.

Jake Seawolf, influencer and photographer for My Patriot Supply, demos a shovel sold by the company in Salt Lake City, Utah on September 11, 2025.Photograph: SINNA NASSERI

Update: 1/8/2025, 10:10 AM EDT: WIRED updated the relationship between the National Advertising Division and the Better Business Bureau.

What Say You?
Let us know what you think about this article in the comments below. Alternatively, you can submit a letter to the editor at mail@wired.com.

Read the whole story
fxer
6 hours ago
reply
Bend, Oregon
acdha
2 days ago
reply
Washington, DC
Share this story
Delete

Think Smaller. Think More Legs.

1 Share

Lotta folk have sent me this, and I want to make one thing absolutely clear: I have never been under any illusions that the meat themed substance that constitutes the McRib has anything to do with pork rib.

But the lawsuit alleged that fans of the sandwich assume they’re biting into pork rib meat, but the McRib does not really contain any.

Despite its name and distinctive shape — its meat patty has been deliberately crafted to resemble a rack of pork ribs—the McRib does not contain any actual pork rib meat at all,” the lawsuit said. “Instead, its meat patty is reconstructed using ground-up portions of lower-grade pork products such as, inter alia, pork shoulder, heart, tripe, and scalded stomach.”

The lawsuit said actual pork rib meat cuts — spareribs and baby back ribs — are premium cuts of pork that are more valuable than lower-quality cuts. Despite not containing any rib meat, the McRib is among the most expensive single-item options offered on the menu at McDonald’s, the lawsuit said.

“The name ‘McRib’ is a deliberate sleight of hand. By including the word “Rib” in the name of the sandwich, McDonald’s knowingly markets the sandwich in a way that deceives reasonable consumers, who reasonably (but mistakenly) believe that a product named the ‘McRib’ will include at least some meaningful quantity of actual pork rib meat, which commands a premium price on the market,” the lawsuit said. “McDonald’s does this despite knowing that the sandwich in fact does not contain any meaningful quantity of actual pork rib meat — indeed, none at all.”

See also Friend of the Blog Erin Petrey’s discussion of what bourbons best pair with the McRib

The post Think Smaller. Think More Legs. appeared first on Lawyers, Guns & Money.

Read the whole story
fxer
13 hours ago
reply
Bend, Oregon
Share this story
Delete

Texas gives DOJ list of its 18 million registered voters

2 Shares
Audio recording is automated for accessibility. Humans wrote and edited the story. See our AI policy, and give us feedback.

This coverage is made possible through Votebeat, a nonpartisan news organization covering local election administration and voting access. Sign up for Votebeat Texas’ free newsletters here.

Texas officials have turned over the state’s voter roll to the U.S. Justice Department, according to a spokesperson for the Texas Secretary of State’s Office, complying with the Trump administration’s demands for access to data on millions of voters across the country.

The Justice Department last fall began asking all 50 states for their voter rolls — massive lists containing significant identifying information on every registered voter in each state — and other election-related data. The Justice Department has said the effort is central to its mission of enforcing election law requiring states to regularly maintain voter lists by searching for and removing ineligible voters.

Alicia Pierce, a spokesperson for the Texas Secretary of State’s Office, told Votebeat and The Texas Tribune that the state had sent its voter roll, which includes information on the approximately 18.4 million voters registered in Texas, to the Justice Department on Dec. 23.

The state included identifiable information about voters, including dates of birth, driver’s license numbers and the last four digits of their Social Security numbers, Pierce said.

Experts and state officials around the country have raised concerns over the legality of the Justice Department’s effort to obtain states’ voter rolls and whether it could compromise voter privacy protections. The Justice Department has said it is entitled to the data under federal law, and withholding it interferes with its ability to exercise oversight and enforce federal election laws.

The department has now sued 23 states and Washington, D.C., for declining to voluntarily turn over their voter rolls. Those states, which include some led by officials of both political parties, have generally argued that states are responsible for voter registration and are barred by state and federal law from sharing certain private information about voters. In an interview with “The Charlie Kirk Show” last month, Assistant Attorney General Harmeet K. Dhillon said 13 states, including Texas, had voluntarily agreed to turn over their voter rolls.

In a letter to Nelson dated Friday and obtained by Votebeat and The Texas Tribune, the Democratic National Committee said the move to hand over the voter roll could violate federal election law.

DNC Chair Ken Martin said the turnover of such data is tantamount to a “big government power grab” and would invite privacy violations and could result in eligible voters being kicked off the rolls. The DNC, he said in a statement, “won’t stand idly by as the Trump DOJ tries to get access to Texas voters’ sensitive information.”

In its letter, Daniel Freeman, the DNC’s litigation director, requested records related to the Justice Department’s request, and warned the party could take further action.

Some election officials and voting rights watchdog groups have raised concerns about what the Justice Department intends to do with the information provided by the states, with some suggesting it may be used to create a national database of voters.

Votebeat and The Texas Tribune have asked the Texas Secretary of State’s Office for a signed copy of the agreement between the state and the Justice Department, known as a memorandum of understanding, governing how the sharing of the voter data would work and steps the state has agreed to take in response to any questions about voter eligibility raised by the Justice Department. The state has not yet released it.

In a proposed memorandum of understanding sent to Wisconsin officials last month and publicly released by state officials, the Justice Department said that upon receiving the state’s voter data, it would check the state’s voter roll for “list maintenance issues, insufficiencies, anomalies or concerns.” The department would then notify the state and give it 45 days to correct any problems. The state would then agree to resubmit the voter roll to the department. Wisconsin declined the agreement, and the Justice Department has since sued the state.

In his letter to Nelson, Freeman identified two potential legal violations associated with some of those clauses, though acknowledged he didn’t yet know whether Texas had signed such an agreement and asked for records.

Freeman wrote that the 45-day removal period as laid out in the public versions of the memorandum would run afoul of a provision in the National Voter Registration Act that lays out specific conditions, such as having missed two elections after receiving a notice from the state, for states to remove registered voters from the rolls.

Freeman also wrote that federal law also bars states from doing systemic voter removals from the rolls within 90 days of a primary or general election. Because Texas has an upcoming March 3 primary, May 26 runoff and Nov. 3 general election, the state cannot conduct such list maintenance until after the runoff, Freeman wrote. The 90-day moratorium would then kick in again on Aug. 6, ahead of the November election.

Texas agreed to the memorandum of understanding and released the data, but told the department that it did so with the understanding it wouldn’t “limit or affect the duties, responsibilities, and rights” of the state under either the NVRA or other federal laws, according to two letters the Texas Secretary of State’s Office sent the Justice Department in December and released to Votebeat and The Texas Tribune.

Natalia Contreras is a reporter for Votebeat in partnership with the Texas Tribune. Contact Natalia at <a href="mailto:ncontreras@votebeat.org">ncontreras@votebeat.org</a>.

Read the whole story
fxer
1 day ago
reply
Bend, Oregon
acdha
1 day ago
reply
Washington, DC
Share this story
Delete

US Black Hawk helicopter trespasses on private Montana ranch to grab elk antlers

1 Share

Collecting fallen (or "shed") elk antlers is a popular pastime in elk-heavy places like Montana, but it's usually a pretty low-tech, on-the-ground affair. That's why last year's story about a US Black Hawk helicopter descending from the skies to harvest shed elk antlers on a ranch was such an odd one.

Was it really possible that US military personnel were using multimillion-dollar government aircraft to land on private property in the Crazy Mountains—yes, that's their actual name—just to grab some antlers valued at a few hundred bucks?

Antler hunt

In May 2025, Montana rancher Linda McMullen received a call from a neighbor. "He said, 'Linda, there’s a green Army helicopter landed on your place, picking up elk antlers,’” McMullen told The New York Times last year. “I said, ‘Are you joking?’ He said, ‘I’m looking at them with binoculars.’”

The local sheriff, who said he was "still trying to figure all this out" at the time, added that this was "the first helicopter I've heard of" regarding shed antler collection.

The Adjutant General for the Montana National Guard, J. Peter Hronek, quickly issued a statement on Facebook "regarding unauthorized use of military aircraft."

In it, Hronek said that he was "aware of an alleged incident involving a Montana Army National Guard helicopter landing on private property without authorization" and that "an internal investigation is underway, and appropriate adverse and/or administrative action will take place if the allegations are determined to be true." The Black Hawk was apparently on a training flight at the time.

The three servicemen on the chopper were eventually charged in Sweet Grass County Court with trespassing. They all pleaded not guilty. This week, pilot Deni Draper changed his plea to "no contest," allowing sentencing to go forward without a trial (but without actually admitting guilt).

According to local reporting, prosecutors had evidence that "no trespassing signs were posted on McMullen's property" and that "Draper admitted to Montana game warden Austin Kassner that he piloted the helicopter and decided to land it." In addition to the neighbor's testimony, "helicopter tire indentations and exhaust marks in the grass" were present at the site of the alleged landing.

The judge has accepted the change of plea and hit Draper with a $500 fine—the maximum penalty. So long as Draper stays out of trouble for the next six months, he will avoid further fines and jail time.

As for the antlers themselves, they are currently held by Montana Fish, Wildlife, and Parks but could go back to McMullen once cases against the other two servicemembers are resolved.

Update: According to a report this week in the Livingston Enterprise, this is not the first time Montana National Guard aircraft have stopped to take antlers.

“By way of a thorough inquiry, we can confirm isolated incidents of collecting antlers (with a military aircraft) have occurred previously,” Lt. Col. Thomas Figarelle of the Montana National Guard told the paper.

Figarelle added that the Guard has now explicitly banned this kind of activity. “(The Montana Army National Guard) issued clear directives no antler collecting of any type is authorized," he added. "This is misuse of government property inconsistent with our standards. We are not going to tolerate it.”

Read full article

Comments



Read the whole story
fxer
1 day ago
reply
Bend, Oregon
Share this story
Delete

Cloudflare defies Italy’s Piracy Shield, won’t block websites on 1.1.1.1 DNS

1 Share

Italy fined Cloudflare 14.2 million euros for refusing to block access to pirate sites on its 1.1.1.1 DNS service, the country's communications regulatory agency, AGCOM, announced yesterday. Cloudflare said it will fight the penalty and threatened to remove all of its servers from Italian cities.

AGCOM issued the fine under Italy's controversial Piracy Shield law, saying that Cloudflare was required to disable DNS resolution of domain names and routing of traffic to IP addresses reported by copyright holders. The law provides for fines up to 2 percent of a company's annual turnover, and the agency said it applied a fine equal to 1 percent.

The fine relates to a blocking order issued to Cloudflare in February 2025. Cloudflare argued that installing a filter applying to the roughly 200 billion daily requests to its DNS system would significantly increase latency and negatively affect DNS resolution for sites that aren't subject to the dispute over piracy.

AGCOM rejected Cloudflare's arguments. The agency said the required blocking would impose no risk on legitimate websites because the targeted IP addresses were all uniquely intended for copyright infringement.

In a September 2025 report on Piracy Shield, researchers said they found "hundreds of legitimate websites unknowingly affected by blocking, unknown operators experiencing service disruption, and illegal streamers continuing to evade enforcement by exploiting the abundance of address space online, leaving behind unusable and polluted address ranges." This is "a conservative lower-bound estimate," the report said.

The Piracy Shield law was adopted in 2024. "To effectively tackle live sports piracy, its broad blocking powers aim to block piracy-related domain names and IP addresses within 30 minutes," TorrentFreak wrote in an article today about the Cloudflare fine.

Cloudflare to fight fine, may withhold services

Cloudflare co-founder and CEO Matthew Prince wrote today that Cloudflare already "had multiple legal challenges pending against the underlying scheme" and will "fight the unjust fine."

"Yesterday a quasi-judicial body in Italy fined Cloudflare $17 million for failing to go along with their scheme to censor the Internet," Prince wrote. He continued:

The scheme, which even the EU has called concerning, required us within a mere 30 minutes of notification to fully censor from the Internet any sites a shadowy cabal of European media elites deemed against their interests. No judicial oversight. No due process. No appeal. No transparency. It required us to not just remove customers, but also censor our 1.1.1.1 DNS resolver meaning it risked blacking out any site on the Internet. And it required us not just to censor the content in Italy but globally. In other words, Italy insists a shadowy, European media cabal should be able to dictate what is and is not allowed online.

Prince said he will discuss the matter with US government officials next week and that Cloudflare is "happy to discuss this with Italian government officials who, so far, have been unwilling to engage beyond issuing fines." In addition to challenging the fine, Prince said Cloudflare is "considering the following actions: 1) discontinuing the millions of dollars in pro bono cyber security services we are providing the upcoming Milano-Cortina Olympics; 2) discontinuing Cloudflare’s Free cyber security services for any Italy-based users; 3) removing all servers from Italian cities; and 4) terminating all plans to build an Italian Cloudflare office or make any investments in the country."

"Play stupid games, win stupid prizes," Prince wrote.

Google also in Piracy Shield crosshairs

AGCOM said today that in the past two years, the Piracy Shield law disabled over 65,000 domain names and about 14,000 IP addresses. Italian authorities also previously ordered Google to block pirate sites at the DNS level.

The Computer & Communications Industry Association (CCIA), a trade group that represents tech companies including Cloudflare and Google, has criticized the Piracy Shield law. "Italian authorities have included virtual private networks (VPN) and public DNS resolvers in the Piracy Shield, which are services fundamental to the protection of free expression and not appropriate tools for blocking," the CCIA said in a January 2025 letter to European Commission officials.

The CCIA added that "the Piracy Shield raises a significant number of concerns which can inadvertently affect legitimate online services, primarily due to the potential for overblocking." The letter said that in October 2024, "Google Drive was mistakenly blocked by the Piracy Shield system, causing a three-hour blackout for all Italian users, while 13.5 percent of users were still blocked at the IP level, and 3 percent were blocked at the DNS level after 12 hours."

The Italian system "aims to automate the blocking process by allowing rights holders to submit IP addresses directly through the platform, following which ISPs have to implement a block," the CCIA said. "Verification procedures between submission and blocking are not clear, and indeed seem to be lacking. Additionally, there is a total lack of redress mechanisms for affected parties, in case a wrong domain or IP address is submitted and blocked."

30-minute blocking prevents "careful verification"

The 30-minute blocking window "leaves extremely limited time for careful verification by ISPs that the submitted destination is indeed being used for piracy purposes," the CCIA said. The trade group also questioned the piracy-reporting system's ties to the organization that runs Italy's top football league.

"Additionally, the fact that the Piracy Shield platform was developed for AGCOM by a company affiliated with Lega Serie A, which is one of the very few entities authorized to report, raises serious questions about the potential conflict of interest exacerbating the lack of transparency issue," the letter said.

A trade group for Italian ISPs has argued that the law requires "filtering and tasks that collide with individual freedoms" and is contrary to European legislation that classifies broadband network services as mere conduits that are exempt from liability.

"On the contrary, in Italy criminal liability has been expressly established for ISPs," Dalia Coffetti, head of regulatory and EU affairs at the Association of Italian Internet Providers, wrote in April 2025. Coffetti argued, "There are better tools to fight piracy, including criminal Law, cooperation between States, and digital solutions that downgrade the quality of the signal broadcast via illegal streaming websites or IPtv. European ISPs are ready to play their part in the battle against piracy, but the solution certainly does not lie in filtering and blocking IP addresses."

Read full article

Comments



Read the whole story
fxer
1 day ago
reply
Bend, Oregon
Share this story
Delete

“Ungentrified” Craigslist may be the last real place on the Internet

1 Comment

The writer and comedian Megan Koester got her first writing job, reviewing Internet pornography, from a Craigslist ad she responded to more than 15 years ago. Several years after that, she used the listings website to find the rent-controlled apartment where she still lives today. When she wanted to buy property, she scrolled through Craigslist and found a parcel of land in the Mojave Desert. She built a dwelling on it (never mind that she’d later discover it was unpermitted) and furnished it entirely with finds from Craigslist’s free section, right down to the laminate flooring, which had previously been used by a production company.

“There’s so many elements of my life that are suffused with Craigslist,” says Koester, 42, whose Instagram account is dedicated, at least in part, to cataloging screenshots of what she has dubbed “harrowing images” from the site’s free section; on the day we speak, she’s wearing a cashmere sweater that cost her nothing, besides the faith it took to respond to an ad with no pictures. “I’m ride or die.”

Koester is one of untold numbers of Craigslist aficionados, many of them in their thirties and forties, who not only still use the old-school classifieds site but also consider it an essential, if anachronistic, part of their everyday lives. It’s a place where anonymity is still possible, where money doesn’t have to be exchanged, and where strangers can make meaningful connections—for romantic pursuits, straightforward transactions, and even to cast unusual creative projects, including experimental TV shows like The Rehearsal on HBO and Amazon Freevee’s Jury Duty. Unlike flashier online marketplaces such as DePop and its parent company, Etsy, or Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist doesn’t use algorithms to track users’ moves and predict what they want to see next. It doesn’t offer public profiles, rating systems, or “likes” and “shares” to dole out like social currency; as a result, Craigslist effectively disincentivizes clout-chasing and virality-seeking—behaviors that are often rewarded on platforms like TikTok, Instagram, and X. It’s a utopian vision of a much earlier, far more earnest Internet.

“The real freaks come out on Craigslist,” says Koester. “There's a purity to it.” Even still, the site is a little tamer than it used to be: Craigslist shut down its “casual encounters” ads and took its personals section offline in 2018, after Congress passed legislation that would’ve put the company on the hook for listings from potential sex traffickers. The “missed connections” section, however, remains active.

The site is what Jessa Lingel, an associate professor of communication at the University of Pennsylvania, has called the “ungentrified” Internet. If that’s the case, then online gentrification has only accelerated in recent years, thanks in part to the proliferation of AI. Even Wikipedia and Reddit, visually basic sites created in the early aughts and with an emphasis similar to Craigslist’s on fostering communities, have both incorporated their own versions of AI tools.

Some might argue that Craigslist, by contrast, is outdated; an article published in this magazine more than 15 years ago called it “underdeveloped” and “unpredictable.” But to the site’s most devoted adherents, that’s precisely its appeal.

“ I think Craigslist is having a revival,” says Kat Toledo, an actor and comedian who regularly uses the site to hire cohosts for her LA-based stand-up show, Besitos. “When something is structured so simply and really does serve the community, and it doesn't ask for much? That’s what survives.”

Toledo started using Craigslist in the 2000s and never stopped. Over the years, she has turned to the site to find romance, housing, and even her current job as an assistant to a forensic psychologist. She’s worked there full-time for nearly two years, defying Craigslist’s reputation as a supplier of potentially sketchy one-off gigs. The stigma of the website, sometimes synonymous with scammers and, in more than one instance, murderers, can be hard to shake. “If I'm not doing a good job,” Toledo says she jokes to her employer, “just remember you found me on Craigslist.”

But for Toledo, the site’s “random factor”—the way it facilitates connection with all kinds of people she might not otherwise interact with—is also what makes it so exciting. Respondents to her ads seeking paid cohosts tend to be “people who almost have nothing to lose, but in a good way, and everything to gain,” she says. There was the born-again Christian who performed a reenactment of her religious awakening and the poet who insisted on doing Toledo’s makeup; others, like the commercial actor who started crying on the phone beforehand, never made it to the stage.

It’s difficult to quantify just how many people actively use Craigslist and how often they click through its listings. The for-profit company is privately owned and doesn’t share data about its users. (Craigslist also didn’t respond to a request for comment.) But according to the Internet data company similarweb, Craigslist draws more than 105 million monthly users, making it the 40th most popular website in the United States—not too shabby for a company that doesn’t spend any money on advertising or marketing. And though Craigslist’s revenue has reportedly plummeted over the past half-dozen years, based on an estimate from an industry analytics firm, it remains enormously profitable. (The company generates revenue by charging a modest fee to publish ads for gigs, certain types of goods, and in some cities, apartments.)

“It’s not a perfect platform by any means, but it does show that you can make a lot of money through an online endeavor that just treats users like they have some autonomy and grants everybody a degree of privacy,” says Lingel. A longtime Craigslist user, she began researching the site after wondering, “Why do all these web 2.0 companies insist that the only way for them to succeed and make money is off the back of user data? There must be other examples out there.”

In her book, Lingel traces the history of the site, which began in 1995 as an email list for a couple hundred San Francisco Bay Area locals to share events, tech news, and job openings. By the end of the decade, engineer Craig Newmark’s humble experiment had evolved into a full-fledged company with an office, a domain name, and a handful of hires. In true Craigslist fashion, Newmark even recruited the company’s CEO, Jim Buckmaster, from an ad he posted to the site, initially seeking a programmer.

The two have gone to great lengths to wrest the company away from corporate interests. When they suspected a looming takeover attempt from eBay, which had purchased a minority stake in Craigslist from a former employee in 2004, Newmark and Buckmaster spent roughly a decade battling the tech behemoth in court. The litigation ended in 2015, with Craigslist buying back its shares and regaining control.

“ They are in lockstep about their early ’90s Internet values,” says Lingel, who credits Newmark and Buckmaster with Craigslist’s long-held aesthetic and ethos: simplicity, privacy, and accessibility. “As long as they're the major shareholders, that will stay that way.”

Craigslist’s refusal to “sell out,” as Koester puts it, is all the more reason to use it. “Not only is there a purity to the fan base or the user base, there’s a purity to the leadership that they’re uncorruptible basically,” says Koester. “I’m gonna keep looking at Craigslist until I die.” She pauses, then shudders: “Or, until Craig dies, I guess.”

This story originally appeared on wired.com.

Read full article

Comments



Read the whole story
fxer
1 day ago
reply
> on the day we speak, she’s wearing a cashmere sweater that cost her nothing, besides the faith it took to respond to an ad with no pictures. “I’m ride or die.”
Bend, Oregon
Share this story
Delete
Next Page of Stories